What happens in your first counselling session?
Your first counselling session is mostly a conversation about what brought you here and whether we feel like a good fit, and nobody expects you to tell your whole story in 50 minutes. We’ll talk about why you’ve come now, we’ll go through the practical bits like confidentiality and fees, and you’ll get to ask me anything you want about how I work. It’s a lot gentler than the version most people have built up in their heads.
I’m writing this for the person who has been “about to book” for weeks, because the not-knowing is usually the hardest part, and I’d rather you walked in knowing exactly what’s coming.
Key takeaways
- The first session is a conversation, not an exam, and you can’t fail it. If anything, you are “testing” to see if you want to work with the counsellor, not the other way around.
- You decide how much you share, and “I’m not ready to talk about that yet” is a complete answer.
- Expect some plain admin: confidentiality and its limits, fees, cancellations, and how sessions run. Mine are 50 minutes.
- A review of almost 400 studies found the quality of the relationship between client and counsellor predicted how therapy went, so the first session is as much about fit as it is about you.
- In one study of health plan members, 34% did not return after a first visit, and the reasons ranged from “this was great, I’m done for now” to “this wasn’t for me”.
What actually happens in a first counselling session?
You arrive, we say hello, and we sort out the small stuff first, like where you’d like to sit, whether you’d like the door open or closed, and whether we use first names. BACP’s guide to counselling says exactly this: that a first session should make you feel at ease and help you work out whether you’re comfortable with your counsellor and their way of working, and I completely agree. Different therapists call this first meeting a taster, a consultation, an intake or an assessment, and Mind lists all 4 of those names, which tells you how little the label matters and how much the feeling in the room does.
Then I ask what’s brought you here now, and I mean now, not in general. Something tipped you from “I could do with some support” to “I’m actually doing this”, and that tipping point is usually the most useful place to start. You might talk for 40 minutes, or you might manage 4 sentences and a long breath, and both are completely fine, because I’m not collecting a case file; I’m getting to know you.
If you’d rather have a no-pressure chat before committing to a full session, you can book a free 20 minute consultation with me here. It’s a chance to hear how I work, ask your questions, and see whether it feels right, and if it doesn’t, you’ve lost nothing. Plus if we do end up working together, it means a lot of the admin has been completed beforehand – offering more space for what you would actually like to talk about in your session.
Do I have to tell you everything in the first session?
No, and I’d go further and say you shouldn’t try. You are allowed to pace your sessions, and pouring out everything to a near stranger in the first hour can leave you feeling exposed and wiped out, which is a rubbish way to start. Keep in mind that people can leave a session exhausted, upset, or overwhelmed if it brings up painful things, and that’s worth knowing before you go in, so you can plan something gentle for afterwards.
What I do instead is follow you. I don’t give advice, and neither should any counsellor, because BACP is clear that counselling is about exploring your thoughts and feelings so you understand yourself and others better, not being told what to do. What I offer are reflections, the odd worksheet, and invitations, and you can take them or leave them. If I ask something and you don’t want to go there, say so, and we’ll go somewhere else.
What will you ask me, and what can I ask you?
I’ll ask about what’s going on, what you’ve tried, who’s around you, and what you’d like things to look like. That last one matters, and I’ll probably ask it a bit sideways, something like “what would an acceptable level of this be for you?”, because most of the people I see aren’t after a total transformation; they want to feel okay, and “okay” is a perfectly good goal. Another one I come back to a lot is “what would you say to a friend in this situation?”, especially if the way you talk about yourself is harsh.
You get questions too, and I’d actively encourage you to use them. Ask how I work, what a typical session looks like, whether I’m registered with a professional body (I’m registered with the BACP, and I work to its ethical framework), and how I use things like creative work and worksheets alongside plain conversation. If you want to know what my integrative way of working actually means in practice, ask me, and I’ll tell you in normal words.
If you’re LGBTQIA+, you shouldn’t have to explain the basics or watch someone’s face while they work out how to react, and it’s completely fair to ask how someone approaches this before you commit. I’ve written about how to tell if your therapist is actually LGBTQIA+ affirming, and you can read about what affirming counselling looks like here.
If you’re neurodivergent, or you suspect you might be, ask for what makes talking easier. That could be getting the questions in advance, having the camera off, listening to music in the background, taking pauses, fidgeting, or telling me that eye contact drains you. Those are totally reasonable requests, not special treatment, and my page on neurodivergent-affirming counselling explains more about how I work.
What do you need to know about confidentiality and fees?
Whatever you tell me stays between us, with a few exceptions that I’ll explain in plain English in the first session so they never come as a surprise. If I believe you or someone else is at serious risk of harm, or if the law requires me to share something, I may have to break confidentiality, and I’ll always tell you first where I can. I also take my work to supervision, which is where counsellors talk through their work with another professional, and I do that without identifying you.
We’ll also cover the dull but necessary bits, which are what a session costs, how cancellations work, how we’ll contact each other, and what happens if you need to pause. Ask about all of it. If money is the thing worrying you, say so early, because session frequency is flexible and fortnightly or monthly sessions are a normal, legitimate way to do this when weekly isn’t affordable.
If things feel too heavy before you’ve seen anyone, Samaritans are free to call on 116 123, any time.
What’s the difference between a consultation, a first session and an NHS assessment?
They do different jobs, and mixing them up is one of the reasons the whole thing feels more daunting than it is.
| Free consultation | First session | NHS Talking Therapies assessment | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Length | 20 minutes | 50 minutes | Varies by service |
| Cost | Free | Paid session | Free |
| Main purpose | See whether we’re a fit, ask your questions | Start the work and agree how we’ll work together | Decide which NHS support suits you |
| Who leads | You ask, I answer. I can also provide some questions to get you talking | You set the pace | A practitioner asks structured questions |
NHS services like North Cumbria Talking Therapies describe their assessment as a structured conversation to work out whether their service can help you, and it’s normally done by phone. That’s a perfectly good route for many people, but it’s a different thing from sitting down with one counsellor you might see every week, which is what a private first session is.
How do you know if the first session went well?
Not by whether you felt better afterwards, because that’s a rubbish measure for a first session. My test is 3 questions, and I’d happily see you judge me on them. Did you say 1 true thing out loud? Did I explain how I work in words you understood? And did you leave knowing what happens next, including that you’re free to say no?
If the answer to all 3 is yes, it went well, even if it felt flat or awkward, and if it’s no to any of them, that’s useful information and not a personal failing.
I rate fit this highly because the research backs it up. A task force led by Christoph Flückiger at the University of Zurich looked at almost 400 studies and found that the quality of the working relationship predicted how therapy went in practically all of them, across different approaches, countries and types of clients. A separate meta-analysis of the first 7 sessions found that early on, a better relationship and lower symptoms tended to feed each other in an upward spiral. So you’re not being picky when you pay attention to how a counsellor makes you feel; you’re doing the thing that matters most.
Here’s the part most therapists leave out. In a study of 2,666 health plan members who answered a survey, 34% didn’t go back for a second visit within 45 days. Those who didn’t return were more likely to rate their experience 10 out of 10 (37% versus 31% of those who did return), but also more likely to give the very lowest ratings (8% versus under 1%). I’m not going to dress that up as proof that not returning is always fine, because for some people it clearly wasn’t, but it does mean that not coming back isn’t automatically a failure either. Sometimes it’s “that was enough for now”, and sometimes it’s “this isn’t the right person”, and the second one is a perfectly good reason to leave.
What if it feels flat, awkward, or I cry, or I go completely blank?
All of that is normal, and none of it means you’re doing it wrong. Plenty of people feel flat, because flat is often exactly what brings them in, that “somewhere in the middle” feeling where nothing’s terrible and nothing’s much good. Others cry in the first 10 minutes and apologise, and I’ll tell you what I tell everyone: there’s nothing to apologise for. Some people go blank, and Mind describes first sessions as overwhelming for some people, so if you find you’ve forgotten everything you meant to say, you’re in very good company.
If you leave unsure, tell me at the next session, or send me a message, and if you decide it wasn’t for me, I’d much rather hear it than have you quietly disappear. You won’t offend me, and I’d rather you found the right fit than sat through 6 sessions out of politeness. If you’re not sure how to judge a counsellor, my post on whether online counselling is effective covers one of the common worries, and if you’re autistic or think you might be, can therapy help autistic adults? is a good place to start.
Do I need to prepare anything?
No, and please don’t write a script. The only prep I’d suggest is jotting down 2 or 3 questions you want to ask me, plus 1 thing you’d like me to know about how you cope with new people, like “I go quiet when I’m nervous” or “I say I’m fine when I’m not”. That’s it. If you’re meeting online, check your connection, and pick a room where you can close the door, and if you can, leave 15 minutes afterwards with nothing scheduled, because going straight from a session into a meeting is brutal.
Frequently asked questions
How long is a first counselling session?
At High Tide, sessions are 50 minutes, and the free consultation beforehand is 20 minutes. Other therapists vary, so check before you book, and ask whether the first session is the same length as the rest.
What should I say in my first counselling session?
Start with what brought you here now, in whatever words come out, and if you don’t know where to begin, “I don’t know where to start” is a great first sentence. You don’t need to cover your whole history, and I’d rather you shared 1 true thing than 10 rehearsed ones.
Is the first counselling session free?
The first full session is a paid session, but I offer a free 20 minute consultation so you can ask questions and see whether it feels right before you commit. NHS Talking Therapies are free, though you may wait for an appointment. When you’re ready, you can also book a session here.
What if I don’t click with my counsellor?
Tell them, or move on, because fit is a legitimate reason to look elsewhere and a good counsellor won’t take it personally.
Will I be diagnosed in the first session?
No. I’m a counsellor, not a diagnostic service, so I won’t label you in a first session. If you think you might be autistic or have ADHD, we can talk about what that’s been like for you, and I can tell you what a formal assessment involves, but a diagnosis comes from a separate assessment.

Leave a Reply